Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> look at groceries. It's a terrible, single-digit percentage margin business but they sell everything from placement in catalogue to whether the product is in a convenient spot on the shelf. That's a clear case where ads make it _cheaper_ for consumers.

I don't follow... it certainly improves the grocer's margins, but how does that do anything at all for the consumer?



I should have been clearer: it's a terrible single-digit percentage business, including the ads. The ads are cross-subsidizing the food.


> The ads are cross-subsidizing the food.

I don't think you were unclear, that's what I understood you to be saying.

Surely, the grocer just pockets the extra ad money? Never in my life have I seen a for-profit corporation voluntarily charge a lower price than the market will bear because they increased their margin by other means.

The ads are also inherently shitty to the producers: they all have to spend money on the grocer's ads now, because if they don't, their competitors will. If you look at it that way, the ads are almost extortion.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: