Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Deliberately making a process inefficient isn't going to fix anything.

More expensive cars means cars are going to be less in demand. Means less cars manufactured, means less jobs for people who make cars.

Also, reworking the auto manufacturing pipeline is going to take decades not days.

Maybe ask yourself if the reason nobody else in the past 30 years has enacted the recent measures of the American government is because they were stupid/lazy/greedy or if it's because they clearly don't work.



>Deliberately making a process inefficient isn't going to fix anything.

Shipping parts to Mexico to have them assembled then shipping it to the US is much less efficient than shipping the parts to the US, manufacturing in the US, then selling in the US.

>More expensive cars means cars are going to be less in demand. Means less cars manufactured, means less jobs for people who make cars.

Less jobs for Mexican labor making cars, more jobs for American labor making cars, that's the objective. It also strengthens unions by increasing headcount and making the threat of moving labor to another country much more expensive. Remember, the discussion is about the plight of the average American worker and how they've been systematically squeezed for 30+ years now due to globalization.

>Also, reworking the auto manufacturing pipeline is going to take decades not days.

Yes, more like years not decades, but ya, not sure why anyone would think it would take days. I suspect a lot of companies will try political maneuvers like waiting out Trump's term, hoping the next guy would be more sensible to their profit needs.

>Maybe ask yourself if the reason nobody else in the past 30 years has enacted the recent measures of the American government is because they were stupid/lazy/greedy or if it's because they clearly don't work.

Companies have a much higher profit margin by using Mexican labor, at the expense of US labor. Those companies also donate a lot of money to campaigns. It's pretty off brand for the Democrats under Clinton/Gore to champion moving thousands of jobs to Mexico under NAFTA. I wonder what motivated them to do that.

It may or may not work, but don't let perfect be the enemy of good. Despair of the average American has a lot of negative, long term social consequences we're currently dealing with, and it's just going to get worse.

Did you know foreign car manufacturers make cars in the US for the US market to avoid tariffs and improve efficiency? They might be on to something.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automobiles_manufactur...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: