COMPLETELY wrong. Telling someone the good as well as the bad is an obvious sandwich - everyone knows this, and the good is completely ignored.
Saying something is good is praise. Saying the bad is critism. Combining them makes some type of praise-criticism hybrid, it does not make good criticism. Let me give you an example of what you are saying:
Hey Dude, I really love the colors on your website. It sucks that your website is really useless to the entire world, but that butterfly you put up there is lovely.
Saying something is good is praise. Saying the bad is critism. Combining them makes some type of praise-criticism hybrid, it does not make good criticism. Let me give you an example of what you are saying:
Hey Dude, I really love the colors on your website. It sucks that your website is really useless to the entire world, but that butterfly you put up there is lovely.
How is that good criticism?