If it created meta concepts from billion words on the internet and has meta models which are correct and are more and better than an avg human, isn't it actually good in reasoning?
Its a very narrow thing to say 'is that so many think its actually reasoning' to say AI is just hype or everything we are doing is a waste etc.
There are human benchmarks they are winning at. The critic could be more that we don't have enough benchmarks.
A majority don’t deny that it’s good. The problem is that so many think it is actually reasoning, believing the answers can be trusted.